So, I was privately asked by a surprising number of people why I had not temporarily changed my Facebook profile picture in a show of support for Paris. I who am usually up on the latest Facebook fads to have not done so was surprising to them. They have a point, but this Facebook Paris profile thing is just one I could not do.
I’ve been to Paris, but even if I had never step foot in the city I still would wholeheartedly feel for what Paris is going through. Just as I felt the outrage for London when they were bombed in 2005, often referred to as 7/7 – the date of the occurrence, just as I know both countries grieved with us here in the United States when 9/11 happened. There is this overwhelming sense of helplessness when one is reading of such a tragedy from afar. After all what can the average Jane and Joe from so far away do right? Granted, most of the world did not have social media, let alone the ability to easily change our profile pics on FB in 2001 or 2005, but today if we can’t really do anything else, the very least we can do, and it really is the very least, is change our profile picture to show our support for Paris right? Right.
When I noticed the changing profile pictures my very first thought was that’s nice. Our hearts are in the right places, I do not make light of it.
I get it.
I really do.
Still, I could not help but ask myself the following – where were these near instantaneous profile pics apps of solidarity for
- Lebanon’s double suicide bomb attacks,
- The suicide bombings in Baghdad,
- The worsening situation in Yemen,
- The decades old Israel / Palestine conflict,
- There was another suicide bombing in Turkey on Sunday, did you know that?
Where are the profile pic apps for any all of them?
A couple of months or so ago, here in the US, Facebookers were able to be “StraightOutta___” whatever they chose to be straight out of in honor/celebration of the release of the movie “Straight Outta Compton”.
A simple movie about a rap group from the 80’s was worthy of being on our profile pictures, yet today is the 580th day since 273 Nigerian school girls were kidnapped by Boko Haram terrorists in Nigeria. 57 escaped and 219 are still missing.
Where’s their profile pic overlay app?
Some have tried to say that most of the above didn’t count because the countries have been in some form of contentious states for years, even decades now. But just because Paris is relatively brand new to this and is considered a safe place, are they more worthy than the Israeli and Palestinian who live with the threat of a bombing as a daily fact of life? Uh. no. And please let it begin and end right here with why tragedies to brown faces get less news coverage and hold our attentions far shorter than tragedies to white faces. I just can’t/won’t go there with that today for we are all hurting.
We cannot look at the events of Paris and not share in their grief. Nor should we ignore the horrors of one tragedy in order to acknowledge the horrors of another. I have no qualms for the many Facebookers who have temporarily changed their profile pictures in solidarity of Paris. Again, because I understand it, I really do. I have changed my Facebook cover to better reflect the suffering seemingly everywhere, for I have no solutions or resolutions either.
It’s a jacked-up world we’re living in and the events in Paris and in Lebanon and in Nigeria… and… and… are already fading into the happier glow of the coming holidays, because it’s all we can do to hold to what little happiness can be found out here for us.
Let’s find it and try to hold on to it long past the times that go by with auld lang syne.
Slice of Life : Two Writing Teachers
You are so right. Our profile pictures could change every day if we listen to the news or read the paper. I have never changed my FB profile picture, not because I don’t care about what happened, but because I rather pray for all those who h ave been affected and pray for the world in which we live.
I totally agree. Have not put the overlay on, because I am tired of the idea that that is doing anything. It is a “feel good” thing, but not a “doing good” thing. I will keep the bumper sticker off my face and with actions and votes try to do the most good. I know we all feel helpless to do anything, but that is a dangerous feeling to have. We cannot be helpless.
That said, I do understand why others have added the overlay to their FB pic. There is nothing wrong with it. It just isn’t enough or all that needs to be done… nor is it really doing anything.
This. Right here is one of the reasons I deactivated my FB account. So much chatter and hype, until the next tragedy or epiphany. Not enough action. And, ditto what Donna said! 🙂
Yes, yes, yes. All of this. Thanks, Rai.
Thanks for sharing this. I think you’re able to articulate clearly & compassionately what I’ve been feeling. A friend of mine recently posted that everyone who is “complaining” about the difference in response between the Paris attacks & those in other countries is participating in the same rhetoric as “all lives matter” vs. #blacklivesmatter. But it’s not about saying what happened in Paris is not worthy of our recognition and solidarity, or saying that it’s not as bad as ____. It’s this, what you say here. Asking where this was for any number of horrific world tragedies that have occurred lately, that’s completely reasonable. & necessary. Good on you for taking the time to express this. & thank you again.